Rivalry I · Joey vs Chris · 13 Meetings · Since 2019
Chris Leads · 7–6
6
Wins
Joey
122.1 avg PPG
Reg 6–5 · Playoff 0–2
Last 5
THE BACKYARD SCRAP
vs
13 Meetings
Chris Leads
Last: 2025 · W16
7
Wins
Chris
129.1 avg PPG
Reg 5–6 · Playoff 2–0
Last 5
Key Moment
Chris posts 200.60 — the highest single-game score in league history. Joey had 132.48. A 68-point margin. The series was never the same.
2021 · Week 5
"In the regular season, it's anyone's game. Come January — it's always Chris."
Rivalry II · Mason vs Connie · 10 Meetings · Since 2019
Deadlocked · 5–5
5
Wins
Mason
122.8 avg PPG
Reg 4–4 · Playoff 1–1
Last 5
THE BLACKOUT BOWL
vs
10 Meetings
Deadlocked
Last: 2025 · W17
5
Wins
Connie
117.9 avg PPG
Reg 4–4 · Playoff 1–1
Last 5
Key Moment
Mason scores 145.66. Connie scores 146.40. A margin of 0.74 — less than a dollar — decides the week. Mason still brings it up.
2020 · Week 7
"Ten games. Five each. The only stat that matters: seventy-four cents."
Rivalry III · Kyle vs Sean · 9 Meetings · Since 2019
Sean Leads · 7–2
2
Wins
Kyle
107.6 avg PPG
Reg 2–6 · Playoff 0–1
Last 5
THE LEPRECHAUN vs GOLIATH
vs
9 Meetings
Sean Leads
Last: 2025 · W4
7
Wins
Sean
129.6 avg PPG
Reg 6–2 · Playoff 1–0
Last 5
Key Moment
Kyle loses by 0.92. His closest game in nine tries — and it still goes the wrong way. There is no comfort in almost.
2022 · Week 9
"Nine meetings. Seven losses. Kyle's still looking for a way out."
Rivalry IV · Isaac vs Connor · 10 Meetings · Since 2020
Deadlocked · 5–5
5
Wins
Isaac
123.5 avg PPG
Reg 5–5 · Playoff 0–0
Last 5
The Holy War
vs
10 Meetings
Deadlocked
Last: 2025 · W14
5
Wins
Connor
131.5 avg PPG
Reg 5–5 · Playoff 0–0
Last 5
Key Moment
Connor erupts for 162.12 — a 64-point demolition. Isaac responded six weeks later with a 55-point blowout of his own. This series does not do subtle.
2024 · Weeks 2 & 13
"Tied all-time. Every game a coin flip — just with bigger margins."
Rivalry V · Evan vs Andrew · 4 Meetings · Since 2023
Deadlocked · 2–2
2
Wins
Evan
113.1 avg PPG
Reg 2–2 · Playoff 0–0
All 4 Games
THE HEARTBURN STRUGGLE
vs
4 Meetings
Deadlocked
Last: 2025 · W13
2
Wins
Andrew
117.8 avg PPG
Reg 2–2 · Playoff 0–0
All 4 Games
Key Moment
Win. Loss. Loss. Win. Four meetings and already mirrored at 2–2. Evan answers Andrew's back-to-back run with a 2025 closer. Now what?
2023–2025 · Every Game
"The series is young. Both are already keeping count."
Rivalry VI · Luke vs Charlie · 10 Meetings · Since 2020
Charlie Leads · 6–4
4
Wins
Luke
114.7 avg PPG
Reg 4–6 · Playoff 0–0
Last 5
THE MID-OFF
vs
10 Meetings
Charlie Leads
Last: 2025 · W12
6
Wins
Charlie
124.2 avg PPG
Reg 6–4 · Playoff 0–0
Last 5
Key Moment
Luke puts up 53.40 — his worst performance in any rivalry matchup. Charlie wins by 62.86. Luke is the 2024 champion. Charlie still has his number.
2022 · Week 14
"Luke has a ring. Charlie has Luke's number."